Have feed back, suggestions, or questions? CLICK HERE to Send us a Message.
Mind Pilot Episode 61
Join Dr. Jana Price-Sharps in a fascinating conversation with Dr. Matthew Sharps on how stress influences our brain and decision-making processes. They explore the science behind the brain's response to high-pressure situations, discussing the energy demands of the brain and the effects of stress on cognitive and perceptual abilities. Drawing from Dr. Sharps' research and publications, this episode sheds light on the challenges and mechanisms of the brain under stress, offering valuable insights for anyone facing high-pressure environments.
Topics Covered:
- STRESS AND DECISION-MAKING: How stress influences cognitive functions and decision-making processes.
- BRAIN UNDER PRESSURE: The physiological and cognitive changes during the fight or flight response.
- INSIGHTS FROM RESEARCH: Dr. Sharps’ findings on stress impact in high-stakes professions like law enforcement and firefighting.
- UNDERSTANDING THE PREFRONTAL CORTEX: The role of the prefrontal cortex in stress and its effects on behavior and perception.
Episode Transcript
Good day. Welcome to Mindpilot. This is This is Dr. Jana Price-Sharps. Today we're going to talk about the brain a little bit more. And I have invited a frequent guest back to talk about this because he is much more knowledgeable about the brain than I am. This is Dr. Matthew Sharps. So when people are going to make a decision, there's a lot of different factors that contribute to how well they make that decision. And one of the things that you talk a lot about in both your books, which I'd like you to introduce in a minute, is what it is that affects people's ability to make good decisions. So, first of all, would you tell us about your books?
Speaker 1Aaron Ross Powell Yeah, I've written uh two of uh several books, the two that we're referencing here are Processing Under Pressure, which is now in the third edition from 2022, and it addresses largely um cognitive science in the realm of law enforcement and uh criminal justice. Because we do see under the stress of the first response role there quite a lot of changes in the way we process information. I also have another uh book, Thinking Under Pressure, and that is in its first edition. That's uh for the fire service, the guide for the fire service. And in that we discuss more about elements of things like PTSD. But the fact is there isn't as much research on the fire service as we'd like. But the same kinds of demands are there. There's continuity in the nervous system. And so what we see in military people in combat, generally there's pretty good continuity there with the realm of law enforcement officers and with the realm of firefighters.
SpeakerOne of the things that you talk about extensively is what happens when people are under pressure and how that influences how they're making decisions. Can you talk a little bit about that?
Speaker 1Aaron Powell Well, yeah, the human fight or flight response is a bit of a problem for the brain. Because the brain is an enormous energy hog. It weighs about 2% of your body weight, okay, but it uses somewhere in the neighborhood of 20 or even more percent of your blood-borne resources. So under stress in the fight or flight response, well, you need your body to be working at a s not really a superhuman level, but at a much above normal level. And so what you wind up having here is the heart rate goes up to pump blood faster. Um your breathing rate will increase, get more oxygen into that blood. And that means your blood pressure goes up too. Now, you the reason you don't usually blow a gasket is because many of the blood vessels in your body engage in what's called vasodilation. They literally get bigger. Some of them can't, but a lot of them do. And so the point is there's all that blood running around your body. Well, it's got to come from somewhere. Now, this is a little oversimplified, but one of the few places you can get additional blood here is out of that enormous energy hog, the brain. The problem is most of the brain, you don't want to really reduce its resources all that much. Okay? We distinguish in the brain really subcortical that's below the cortex structures and cortical structures. Now, the cortex is the big gray wrinkly bit that almost everybody references when they're talking about a brain, okay? The subcortical structures, though, are perhaps even more interesting because a lot of those toward the base of the brain, the hind brain, are basically involved in keeping you alive, regulating things like heart rate and breathing. There's a big structure at the base of the brain at the back called the cerebellum, and it does a whole lot of things for you. It is involved in motor coordination and an established motor program, it's meaning if you know how to box or wrestle or dance or sew, a lot of those responses are are there in the cerebellum. So if you're a good juggler, that those pro those programs, excuse me, are there. It also contributes to cognitive fluidity, but it it's such a very primitive ancient structure, it winds up with its own little junction box, basically to communicate with the rest of the brain. Now, down there below the cortex, you also have, oh my goodness, so many things. The hippocampus, which basically is where you turn short-term into long-term memory. The thalamus, because the brain has got so much going on, it basically needs a switchboard that communicates with other systems. So the reason I'm really bringing up the thalamus is below that is the hypothalamus. That's the major organ that uh I know uh that you've talked about quite a f quite a bit in other uh other podcasts here. The organ of homeostasis, the organ that really maintains the state you need to be in, whether it's a high-level state of fight or flight or a calmer state in normal life. And then you're attached in there also with the amygdala, which is an amazing structure, having a lot to do with anxiety and aggression. It also is involved in the binding of emotional qualities to memory. So you've got all these structures on there. Now you think about that. Do you really want to shut any of those off in the middle of a fight? Well, that would be no. So where do we get this energy? Well, there's the cortex. Now, the cortex comes in two halves. They're called the hemispheres, okay? And the brain isn't really spherical, but it's roughly round, so it kind of makes sense. And there's four lobes on each hemisphere. There's the temporal lobe right under your temple, really. There's the occipital lobe at the back of the head. That's easy to remember because occipital deals with ocular things. Vision is mainly there in the occipital lobe. But the temporal lobe has a lot of visual functions too. Down at the base of it, we call the ventral pathways where you identify things. And up at the top of it, we call it the dorsal pathway, the top of the temporal lobe, has a role in identifying where things are. There's a wonderful structure in there also that deals with face recognition and also auditory cortex. That's where your hearing goes. So we have the temporal and occipital lobes. Do those sound like things you want to shut down when you're under stress? It's not a good idea to go blind when you're fighting a fire or in combat, is it? You also want to know what and where things are. If you've got a gigantic sugar pine on fire in front of you in Madeira County, it's a very good idea not to decide that it's a bunch of roses in a nice meadow in Lincolnshire. You can't shut that stuff off. Now you can shut down your hearing a little bit. And by the way, you do. The number one cognitive and perceptual change under high stress is for most people, sounds seem quieter. For some people they seem louder, for most quieter. But that leaves us, you really can't shut most of that stuff down, can you? And then you've got the parietal lobe. That's right up there at the back of the head, really, but in front of the occipital lobe, right? Well, that has a lot to do with understanding, including the understanding of where your body is. Now, again, you don't really want to shut down a lot of those functions. And the frontal lobes, okay. Well, you've got cortex there that really plans your motions and gives you stop or go codes for your motions and other cortex that tells you what it's okay to move now, okay, and that's read by a wonderful structure at the front of the parietal lobes that tells you, okay, you've moved to the right place, you've moved to the wrong place, you've got to correct it. You really can't shut any of that stuff down very much, can you? But the one place you can kinda well, you don't let me put this way, under high stress, you're probably not solving differential equations. You can shut down a little bit parts of the prefrontal cortex. It's the very front of the front, right behind your right behind uh your your forehead. And it has several different parts, too. But the gist of it is that when you need all that bloodborne resources, and again, I'm I'm simplifying this quite quite a bit. There are a few lovely 600-page books you can read about this. But the fact is you have less blood-borne resources available, let's put it that way, to the prefrontal cortex. Even the way the blood vessels do this with reference to blood chemistry is insanely complex. But the fact is you're not getting as much blood flow I don't want to say that. As many blood-borne resources to the prefrontal cortex. Which means you ain't gonna be able to solve differential equations, and you're probably gonna use the word ain't, okay? You're going to lose some of your cognitive and perceptual acuity. Tunnel vision is one of the consequences of this reduction. You may not see the fire creeping around behind you. In a law enforcement context, you may not see you maybe so focused on the you finally got your target, the bad guy. You caught the bad guy you've caught the evil puppy kicker of Pango Pango or something. You're so focused on him, and it's his buddy in the corner that uh that shoots at you. Okay? That's television. There's a whole whole pleth of these factors. I discuss them in in depth in processing under pressure, and I also discuss them in thinking under pressure myself. There are many other sources on on these perceptual and cognitive anomalies, but I talk about them specifically in processing under pressure for the law enforcement community, in thinking under pressure for fire and other emergency workers. But whole variety of these factors, because the prefrontal cortex is not getting the usual amount of juice here. Now, that some special significance with reference to aggressive response, okay? Because down there deep in the uh part of the brain that we actually share with dinosaurs, it's down there in your inner dinosaur, right? Is this uh this wonderful structure of the amygdala, okay, which uh tends to allow you, and in in concert with other structures, this is very complicated complicated, but it lets you make aggressive responses, proper aggressive responses. Lots of times you might want to make an aggressive response. You you might want to call your boss a human hemorrhoid or something, and it's a bad idea. Well, it's part of the prefrontal cortex that will prevent you from doing that. The prefrontal cortex will inhibit some of these lower, more inner dinosaur responses. Okay, because if inner dinosaurs going rarg and the prefrontal cortex is going, hold it. With less resources in the prefrontal cortex, the safety is off. You've probably seen this in some boring meeting where the person up front is saying incredibly stupid things. Somebody will stand up and basically start suggesting they're a fool. Okay, terrible consequences for their career, but the prefrontal cortex isn't on duty thinking about that. It's basically, so to speak, gone on vacation. Your prefrontal cortex is hanging around in in Maui with a metaphorical Mai Tai, right? While your lower part of your brain is going, Yahoo, it's time for the rodeo. So you're not thinking through the consequences. You just sort of are gonna light up the roof and go. And this these are consequences of the way the brain is responding to stress. Now, again, there's a whole variety of wonderful 600-page books you can read on this. My my books are nowhere near 600 pages, and they're written much more much more for for first responders to be able to deal with. But there's a lot to this, but this is the basis of it, I think, that you're going to r reduce and you can't help it, no matter how smart you started out, you're gonna reduce some of your intellectual and even perceptual acuity under high stress. And much of this d much of this, we can say this very safely, much of this has to do with the reduction of prefrontal function under stress.
SpeakerSo what happens with somebody who's under chronic stress and is exhausted?
Speaker 1Well, that's a that's a very deep problem because the brain, the brain and the body really can't keep that up forever. In a previous podcast, we talked about an older theory, and it's been modified since then. But the theory of Celier, Hans Cellier psychologist, has said that you go through an alarm response where you're basically getting ready to fight the saber-toothed tiger or or or or the organized crime or or or you know the fire. If that goes on too long, the body enters a state of resistance where it tries to keep this adrenal fight or flight response going. And if there is not some relief, uh the body and the brain will enter a stage of exhaustion. Now this is outside my scope, so I don't want to deal with it very much, but you'll wind up with physiologically things like more infl more inflammation, more difficulty with resource allocation, more difficulty with the the handling of food products, et cetera, inside the body. But all that can result in stress-related illnesses. And of course, if your prefrontal cortex isn't operating very well, uh you may be killed by something you didn't notice that comes up behind you. So there's all sorts of nasty consequences that can happen of being in fight or flight for too long.
SpeakerSo it seems like one of the problems would be if your prefrontal cortex is not working as well as it should be, then you also may not be thinking about, you know, when I get home, I really should go to sleep. Maybe I shouldn't go and party with my friends and then drive while I've been drinking. Or, you know, in other words, that impulsive part of the brain may be kind of running the show more, and that's where some of the bad decisions could come into.
Speaker 1Oh, absolutely. Absolutely. Some of the symptoms that we see there are intrusive thoughts, okay? You may suddenly it may be absolutely essential that you blurt out that your boss is a human hemorrhoid. You really feel the need to do that, okay? Another consequence is the tunnel vision. Now, I'm playing a little fast and loose with this, because tunnel vision really applies to you see what's right out in front of you but miss what's on the periphery. But you have a kind of analog of that in cognition as well, where you're just not seeing the possibilities of doing something other than the way I'm doing it, and the way I'm doing it isn't working. But another factor there we see in automatic pilot, people tend to go on they tend to go to their habitual responses. You tend not to innovate. You're going to go back to whatever your training and experience are. Well, if your training and experience for the last 21 days was giving orders and taking orders, okay? Let's say you're on in a fire, and I'm dealing with all first responders, really. You could be on a long operation, a long undercover operation, you could be in a fire situation, okay? And you don't say a heck of a lot of, you know, please thank you and pass the T under those circumstances. It's pretty much the order, yes, sir, I'll do this, okay, get over there. No, no, no, pull that machine back now, okay? Um basically you're being, if you think about it, quite rude, but you don't have time to do anything else. And you just get used to that, and everybody around you does it, and nobody thinks it's rude. Okay? Then you get home, and you're in this habitual state that you've been in for the last three weeks. Your homeostatic level has shifted to a higher level of arousal, and you you're kind of flipping back and forth on that wonderful Yerkes-Dotson curve we talk about, where you're not functioning as well under there- there are complications to that, obviously. But uh there are uh high arousal, you're not thinking as well, very low arousal, you're not thinking as well. So you come through the door and you notice things are not clean and neat, okay? I I've never yet seen a fire engine that wasn't neat. Everything has to be in the right place. It's like a ship at sea, okay? Police cars, they they may not be neat by the end of the shift, but they start you know where things are at the beginning of the shift. Um, ordinary houses aren't like that. And you come through the door and you notice the dishes haven't been done, and there's a sort of feral quality of the child rearing, okay? And what you start doing is shouting at your spouse. Okay, I want this kid in bed. I want this kid over there. This kid doesn't even belong here. Send him home. I want this kid. Don't feed him any cheese. You know what he smells like. This kid needs a bathtub now. Let's move, let's move. And your spouse is basically going, I'm thinking divorce. Um and you go, suddenly there you are going, what happened? Because the prefrontal cortex is also where we consider the consequences of our actions. Why is the spouse behaving in this odd manner? Why is he or she yelling at me? Okay. Well, it's because you just spent 10 minutes yelling. No, you weren't yelling, you were giving orders. Oh dear. It's the wrong place for it, isn't it? But your ability to do the critical reasoning, and that's not really a technical term, but critical reasoning, thinking about what the hell am I doing next? That is a big part of the fight or flight response, and that's one reason why we want very realistic. I talk about this in many of my classes and seminars. Very realistic, three-dimensional training with consequences, not as severe consequences as you'd have in the field. But when you go in the field, you are going to respond to your training and experience. I discussed this in detail in processing under pressure to some degree and thinking under pressure. If that training and experience has not been appropriate to the situation, then the consequences can literally be lethal. If it has been appropriate to the situation, you're going to succeed. Because you're going to fall-y can't be innovative at that moment. You're going to fall back on your training and your experience. So if you've had proper training in mental resiliency and dealing with your family when you get home, and you've got some of the, and again, I'm trespassing much more into your department than mine. If you've got appropriately trained psychological technologies that a clinician who gets it, okay, who understands what you're dealing with, has given you, prepared you, then you can use this technique, this technique, this other technique. So when you come through the door, you're not going to start ordering your spouse and children away around the way you normally order your crew around in a fire situation, or the way if you if you're command if you're an incident commander someplace in a law enforcement situation, you you you don't have time for please thank you past the tea. You're giving orders. And that's not going to work well when you come home to your kid's birthday party.
SpeakerSo if they train, so to speak, on what they need to do when they go home and they start practicing that, because you can't just be told that you actually have to practice that. Over time that can begin to shift so that that also becomes a script for home life. In other words, no, I'm at Jimmy's birthday party, so this is how I act because this is how I have practiced acting once I get home.
Speaker 1Is that well, that's exactly correct. Think about law enforcement or the fire service, okay? Detective duties are very different from patrol. The same person may have learned both sets of duties and they're there, and they'll use them in different settings when they have to, okay? Uh fire people, there's a tremendous difference, obviously, between fighting a structure fire on average and fighting a forest fire. Fire service personnel have that in have that in their minds. Well, it's exactly the same thing. You have training for the different situations you're going to deal with, provided it's good training. But certainly there was a wonderful study done back in 2004 of college students who learned to juggle of all things, okay? And what was found was that the parts of the brain that are involved in those visual motor activities actually got a bit bigger when they learned to do that. Now, the adult brain cells weren't reproducing themselves. As far as we know, that's that's impossible with the possible exception of a couple of specific structures, okay? But what was happening is those brain cells were making more connections, uh more and better connections. So we know the brain itself changes when you train it. And what you're doing there is simply adding in a way, it's sort of adding more and better specialized tools to an already existing toolbox, okay? Coming home to the kid's birthday party and, so to speak, using the sledgehammer is a bad idea. You need somewhat more refined tools. And that's where that's where these resiliency technologies, these psychological technologies, the the the clinician who gets it can be very helpful for in providing those to the uh to the firefighter, the officer, the first responder. But they do have to be practiced. Okay. When the kids well excuse me, when the college students stopped juggling, those parts of the brain get smaller again. Now they never got as small as they'd started out, because at one point the brain had been forced to learn to juggle. So the basic concept is the brain might have to do that again. So it sort of maintains maintains the basic skeleton of the abilities. Okay, that's the that may be going a bit far with the data, but it it doesn't it's not going that far. Okay. But the So in other words, though, if you don't use something for a while and then you use it again, it's usually easier to bring it back than if you had to learn it from scratch. Okay. But the fact is, practice is essential. You have to have it's kind of what I call the bathing effect. Yeah, I'm in favor of bathing. I hope you are too. But if you had one bath in the late spring of 1997, it's a good bit you need to have another one. Okay? Um these things have to be practiced. They have to be r rather continually acknowledged and presented to the nervous system to keep the to keep them away. It's exactly the same as perishable skills in any area. You know, that's uh that is true. It's essentially exactly the same as perishable skills in the tactical realm and the realm of firefighting. You have to practice, but you have to have have the skills in the first place to develop the necessary resiliency.
SpeakerIt makes me think of a comment that I often hear from combat vets, from fire personnel, from law enforcement, that they don't take it home and they don't take the job home. And one of the things that is the problem with that idea is you have the same brain. It's it's not like you unscrew your brain and set it aside and screw on another brain when you walk into the house. And now I know that what your many of you mean is that you don't talk in depth to your loved ones about what you've seen or what you've gone through. But your brain is still the same brain that went through all of that. And so if you have not developed those, again, uh perishable skills of how to transition from work to home, you're not going to transition. You're you're going to be treating it as if you're still at work. So becoming very aware of that and also understanding how your brain is functioning. Uh, it's not a yes or no, turn on the light switch, turn off the light switch kind of problem. It's understanding what you're doing at work and then what you want to do at home that is different, and then practicing what you want to do at home in hopefully at a time when you're not full of adrenaline and cortisol, so that you begin to develop those resiliency habits that are effective on the in the home environment. Does that make sense?
Speaker 1Absolutely. That's exactly correct.
SpeakerOkay. So evaluate. Think about who do you want to be when you're at home, who do you want to be at work, what's important, and then put together a training program for yourself. You know, if you will do that, you will be so much more effective. But that that requires taking a little bit of downtime and really thinking about who is it you want to be wherever you're at, and then practicing that because they may not be automatic skills. They are probably skills that you'll have to learn, as we all do, right? And mental health skills are very much perishable skills. So as Dr. Sharp said, you know, you don't just bathe once, right? You have to this is these are skills that you have to stay practicing and you have to keep in the front part of your mind when you're transitioning from one environment to the other. I hope this has been helpful. Thank you so much for joining. You have the right to have a happy life. So think about what we're talking about and how you can implement this into your life so that you can have happier relationships. You can feel better when you wake up in the morning. You have that right. So, thank you for joining us. This is Dr. Jana Price-Sharps from Mindpilot.